.
Feedback

Is New TSA Knife Policy Good Sense—or Airline Danger?

The Transportation Security Administration eases rules on allowing passengers to carry pocketknives.

Attention—air travelers: Packing a yogurt in your carry-on is still verboten, but packing a Swiss Army knife is now OK. The federal agency tasked with overseeing airline safety said Tuesday it is changing its policy on some items passengers are allowed to take onboard.

Diamond Bar and Walnut residents, have you had an item confiscated at the airport by the TSA? Does this policy change make sense to you? Tell us in comments.

The decision by the Transportation Security Administration to ease rules on pocketknives and some sports equipment has sparked opposition from those who work in the airline industry and the families of 9/11 victims.

A spokesman for TSA Administrator John S. Pistole said the decision was made after a committee reviewed the items “based on an overall risk-based security approach.”

Pocketknives with blades less than 2.36 inches long and less than half an inch wide are now permitted in the cabins of commercial flights, as are souvenir bats, golf clubs, hockey sticks, and pool cues in carry-on bags.

[What's permitted/prohibited? See the TSA .pdfs in the media box attached to this article.]

The policy change takes affect April 25.

The decision was denounced by the Allied Pilots Association, the union that represents American Airlines pilots.

"It represents a significant step backward in security," spokesman Gregg Overman told the Los Angeles Times.

Stacy K. Martin, president of Southwest Airlines' flight attendants union, TWU Local 556, also opposed the change, telling the LATimes:

“While we agree that a passenger wielding a small knife or swinging a golf club or hockey stick poses less of a threat to the pilot locked in the cockpit, these are real threats to passengers and flight attendants in the passenger cabin.”

An Orlando Business Journal report says the Sept. 11 terrorist attacks have been forgotten.

“It’s as if we didn’t learn anything from 9/11,” said George Randall Taylor, head of the air marshal unit of the Federal Law Enforcement Officers Association. “Flight attendants are going to be sitting ducks.”

And the AP’s Karen Mathews is reporting outrage among relatives of those who died on United Flight 93.

It’s a “dreadful mistake to loosen the rules,” said Alice Hoagland, whose son Mark Bingham was a leader of the attempt to take back Flight 93.

“We are increasing the chances of flight attendants and passengers being attacked while in the air,” she said. “This decision was made in order to make the TSA look a little better, to ease up on the standard so they won't have egg on their face.”

ALSO READ: Blades in Your Bags? 12 Crazy TSA Airport Finds in California

Critics of the move say folding knives are hard to find with X-ray screening, and missing them is lowering the performance testing rates of agency employees.

The TSA says the policy aligns with the standards of international carriers and allows airport security screeners to focus on threats such as bombs.

Have you had an item confiscated by the TSA? Does this policy change make sense to you? Tell us in the comments section below.

Two Sides March 11, 2013 at 12:24 pm
NO! Why take a chance? Everyone is trained not to bring them now. Why step backwards? If someone really wants/needs a knife, pack it in checked luggage. I am sure they can live without it during flight and it helps others to "live" without it being a risk in the wrong hands. Especially with possible other security cutbacks (no pun intended). Why take unnecessary risk?
Michael W March 12, 2013 at 02:29 am
We need the freedom to take the things we are used to on a plane as AMERICANS. We are not meek Frenchmen or Belgians. This is a fine policy. Big change after 911- pilots have guns now, THAT is why US planes aren't high jacked anymore. Don't be afraid of a Swiss Army knife, a Pop-Tart shaped like a pistol, or a cupcake with a plastic toy soldier on it.
Robert Corona March 12, 2013 at 01:28 pm
Agree with Michael... they should let us bring in more than little pocket knives..
The security wait is horrible! When was the last time there was a skyjacking? Come on, lets get our lives back to normal. We are letting these idiots take over our lives.. Course knowing the airlines,,, they are getting ready for a surcharge for pocketknives!
Walnut Watchdog March 12, 2013 at 02:38 pm
The 9/11 hijackers used box cutters with one inch blades. It is very easy to sharpen a cheap pocketknife to a very sharp edge...A 2.36 inch blade, finely honed to a sharp edge is extremely dangerous. I support the pilots and stewardesses who are fearful of this erosion in public safety. A sharpened knife 2.36 inches long could easily be used to cut a carotid artery leading to death and complete body blood loss in just a few seconds. The 9/11 hijackers were not Americans, but killed thousands of people in a few minutes with basically one inch box cutters. The pilot doors are stronger now, but can be breached. That would be the only justification for firing a handgun on an aircraft which is extremely dangerous, and a last resort due to the danger to passengers or explosive decompression.
Robert Corona March 12, 2013 at 07:06 pm
That was a long long time ago... now there are air marshalls... AND doubt that
they could take over a plane with box cutters now. I think they would get stampeded. That experience was totally new and some passengers thought it was a joke. Only way they would skyjack a plane now is with guns.

Newsletter & Alerts

Get the best stories each day and important breaking news

Subscribe

Not from Diamond Bar-Walnut Patch? Find your Local Patch »

Note Article
Just a short thought to get the word out quickly about anything in your neighborhood.
Share something with your neighbors. Write a new post... What's up? Make an announcement, speak your mind, or sell something
Concerned Parent June 11, 2013 at 09:58 am
At least we should let people sleep on the weekends! I remember the last memorial weekend, whenRead More Susan Park was full of baseball banging noises starting at 6:30 am and then screaming and kicking at 7 am. Can Walnut Counsel fix that non-sense??
Michael W June 11, 2013 at 07:27 pm
CP is right, the Walnut Council should be working on REAL quality of life issues, even though theyRead More aren't so glamorous. I'd like to see this issue solved/leaf blowers BANNED verses the Council putting in another red-light camera or parking meters to extort money from Mt. Sac students.
Too Shy June 17, 2013 at 01:25 pm
During the hotter months, the days are longer, people try to do outdoor work really early or reallyRead More late since it's cooler. What about all the barking noise created when people walk their dogs really early or really late? These people usually have their favorite spots and they just stand there forever while all the dogs in the street are going crazy. Shouldn't this be banned too?
Melanie C. Johnson (Editor) May 31, 2013 at 11:53 am
Hello Me. Sure. I have a press release to post from the district on some Nogales Gates MillenniumRead More scholars. I just haven't had a chance to post yet. I have a little more time because Nogales hasn't had its graduation yet while DB, DR, and WHS all have had theirs. You can also use this announcement section to post stuff happening at Nogales that you want the community to know about on Patch.
The first in the Malone mystery seriess
pamylla May 28, 2013 at 09:57 am
Why post this book as if it is NEWS? The headline read as if it were actual news, not a bookRead More review. Shouldn't there be a separate section for books and such?
Patricia Gligor May 28, 2013 at 02:54 pm
I agree but, if there is, I couldn't find it. And, actually, it isn't a book review; it's a bookRead More blurb for the first novel in my Malone mystery series.